You old farts know not of which you speak.
As wreckingball mentioned in the first post, there was a distinct market for Live 100.5. There were no other alternatives for alternative. Talk radio? Obviously, the suits are basing talk radio numbers off of JOX. I'm sure JOX does quite well. There's a ton of people obsessed with college football in this city. Just because that does well doesn't mean any old hack talking into a microphone about anything will automatically be successful. First they took the X, then they took 105.5 the Vulcan and turned it into some shit-tacular talk radio. How's that working out for them? Has anyone even ever listened to that station?
Because I'm not old, everyone I know listened to 100.5 primarily.
Facebook says there are 15,732 people in the Birmingham area that cared enough about trying to save the station that they joined this facebook group.
http://www.facebook.com/search/?q=live+100.5&init=quick#!/group.php?gid=326223102222&ref=ss
There are probably double that that listen to the station regularly but don't give a shit about facebook groups (myself), or those that realized it was a lost cause (again, myself), those that aren't on facebook, or those that didn't even know they were going off the air.
And the fact that popular = good? In the realm of music?
Wow.
Kesha > The White Stripes, for example?
Wow.