please circle the name that doesn't belong...

[chinook]

peyton manning
kellen moore
colt McCoy
david green

ridiculous.  sickening. spudpacker.

[jmar]

peyton manning
kellen moore
colt McCoy
david green

ridiculous.  sickening. spudpacker.

I'll guess Green since I haven't heard his name mentioned recently.
Correction, Green was once a Colt in '08, McCoy is a lifelong Colt and then there is All-Pro Peyton.
Spudpacker was the clue. What has the little lefty done to offend thee nookie?

[The Six]

peyton manning
kellen moore
colt McCoy
david green

ridiculous.  sickening. spudpacker.

Peyton Manning? I think he stands above the rest.

Kellen Moore - yet to leave college and be tested in pros.

Colt McCoy - took a shot in the shoulder and resurfaced in Cleveland but it's still Cleveland.

David Green - Won a bunch of games, no national title, drafted by Seahawks and never played meaningful time in the NFL.

[djsimp]

Well I circled one but now I can't get the ink off my puter screen.

[Jumbo]

Well I circled one but now I can't get the ink off my puter screen.

Real life problems.

[JR4AU]

peyton manning
kellen moore
colt McCoy
david green

ridiculous.  sickening. spudpacker.

Why don't you tell us?  Was there some significance in only capitalizing McCoy's last name?  A clue perhaps?

[Godfather]

I think it's a clue of some upcoming specials.