The second season of Paramount's Strange New Worlds Star Trek show was entertaining enough to prompt me to revisit the original series on Pluto. That led me to boldly going to...
Star Trek: The Motion Picture
Lots went wrong here. It was good to get the band back together, but well... damn.
The muted color pajama-looking uniforms were atrocious. Everybody was in some shade of beige or off-white.
Series creator Gene Rodenberry was an avowed athiest, so it wasn't surprising to see this movie tackle the concept of God - which in his mind couldn't possibly exist. It was a theme often visited on the original series as various other-worldly beings attempted to take the mantle of some sort of God.
It was so bad and so cheese-filled, I'm surprised the remainder of the films were green-lit. The nostalgia factor that drove fans to the theaters made up for a lot of shortcomings. You'd have to understand the cult-level status the three uneven seasons of the original series earned to get why this movie was such a big deal in 1979. Fans were willing to overlook a lot of craptastic nonsense to see Kirk, Spock, Uhura, Checkov, Sulu, Scotty, and Bones together again.
In a weird trivia note, the theme for this film was repurposed as the theme for Next Generation. That never made sense. I guess they just didn't want to pay for new music.
The Wrath of Khan
The best of the Star Trek films (from what I remember) still has some faults, but it's the only one of the original cast efforts that sort of holds up and also hews truer to the original concept.
Ricardo Montalban (Khan) was a bulked up son-of-a-bitch at 60 in this film. Bulked to the point that people have often accused him of wearing a prosthetic chest. He didn't.
No question the special effects were rudimentary. The ear worm closeup was amazing for its time but really doesn't measure up. I remember watching it in theaters and being grossed out, but now it's just cringe-inducing for its sheer awfulness.
Still, this was what the series was about. Kirk using his wits and relying on his team to defeat a stonger, more powerful opponent.
Montalban really made this movie, though. His performance elevated the entire exercise.
Enjoyed this one.
The Search for Spock
Leonard Nimoy (Spock) directed this transporter full of tribble shit.
Wrong in so many directions. Everything from Checkov's pageboy-collared pepto bismol pantstuit to Miguel Ferrer sitting at a control deck on the bridge to Christopher Lloyd channeling Doc as a Klingon was bad. Just so bad.
The bar scene where McCoy/Spock is looking for a transport stole directly from Star Wars IV: New Hope while simultaneously foreshadowing Jar Jar Binks was cringeworthy.
I know there are more, but this is easily my least favorite so far.
This whole movie came about because Nimoy regretted demanding his character to die at the end of Khan and decided the perpetual paydays might not be such a bad idea. So they made an entire film to allow him to resurrect himself using some tacked on footage from Khan.
Everything about this movie looked cheap, too. The original series was well known for its cheapness. Cardboard sets and Christmas lights. A big budget movie shouldn't give that feel.
- Reviews for 4, 5, 6, etc. - coming as soon as I get around to watching them. FWIW, I have never watched TNG and I have no intention of ever watching it or any of the movies it spawned. I'm less interested in Deep Space Nine, Voyager, or Discovery. I've heard Enterprise is possibly worth a look, but I'm not sure I'll ever get to that either.
Couple of odd notes:
Kirk is a TERRIBLE actor. All of them are, frankly.
Spock (perhaps purposely) did not age well at all. He was just 48 when Star Trek: TMP was aired and looked at least a decade older.
The would have been better off sticking with the original uniforms and color schemes. They were almost as bad as KISS
going from the streamlined early look to the bat wings to the demon suit that looked like chewed up tinfoil to the enormous capes to the lycra From the Elder era to the fruity neon glam and then back to the beginning again. The unis in The Motion Picture were the worst, but they got progressively more complicated and bulky as each film came out. Should have just hung on to the blue, red and yellow originals.