Transformers 4: Age of Ex-stink-tion
First let me say that to this point I liked all the Transformers movies, even the middle one that went to Egypt.
This one? It veered wildly off the track I thought.
Casting: C-
Wahlberg was just barely okay. Shaia Labeouf was scads better as Bumblebee's ward. The daughter (cute) was awful. The boyfriend was terrible. Tucci was good but the rest was just bad. Didn't even much enjoy John Goodman's babbling as an Autobot. Best role went to Erlich from Silicon Valley, but his (much welcome) commentary was rubbed out far too soon. No Lebouf, no Tyrese, no Duhamel, no Tutturo, no Malkovich, no Dunn and White, no Jeong, no Tudyk and the movie suffered BADLY for it.
Length: F
The movie ran 2:37 and it felt every single minute of it. It could have been cut by an hour without losing a beat.
Story: F
Too many confusing things going on. Optimus acted like a pissy bitch far too often. A lot of it just didn't make sense. I'm willing to suspend a lot of logic in a movie that features cars that turn into robots, but this was just too much. The one-note "don't touch my daughter" banter between Wahlberg and the boyfriend wore thin after the second joke. Frasier was a flop as the human big bad. Unlike the other three, I ceased to care about an hour and a half in. The interactions, emotions and reactions just didn't ring true. Felt forced. Michael Bay is great at crafting amazing CGI action and destruction, but (even in the first three) he flounders when asked to write/film human emotion sequences. The dialogue was stilted and silly. The girl (cute) was awful. Did I mention that? The film opened with a brief bit of exposition about the aftermath of the Chicago destruction from the last film, even noting the massive human and financial cost of the carnage. Would have been a much better film if it had just stayed there and explored the tenuous relationship with robots that should defend us and a human population shellshocked by the ravages of a war unlike any ever waged on American soil. Instead it muddled around with a bunch of other garbage. By the time one of the the big bads was finally dispatched -- a moment that was designed to bring triumphant cheers -- it just fizzled, lost in the rampant and wanton destruction.
Action: C
Lots and lots and lots of fights and buildings shattering and people/robots flying around. Just once i'd like to see a movie of this nature scale back on demolishing cities (Chicago and Hong Kong in this case) and build a different kind of tension. We've watched The Avengers maul New York, Superman shred Gotham, Godzilla flatten Tokyo, Captain America destroy buildings in some town, Transformers shatter Chicago once before and on and on. It's gotten to be too much. There are some beautiful shots of buildings imploding and exploding but at this point it just seems stale. Seen it.
Plot: F
What? What was it? There will be some who will rip me on this topic, claiming I'm not astute enough to see the doors that were opened by the muddled and open-ended topics. Yeah, I realize that there are a number of possibilities set up by the ending. Bad guys still exist, Optimus can possibly explore where they actually came from, some dinosaurs just wandered off to who knows where. But none of that moves me. I wasn't invested AT ALL in the lead characters. Was hoping one or more of them would just die already.
Music: F-
The earlier films had Linkin Park and some other decent music. This didn't. The "songs" it played were out of place and just terrible, terrible.
Love the Transformers franchise but was terribly disappointed in this one. It (like this review) was overly long, ponderous, fatuous and blundering. It took all the things I liked about the first films and pissed on them. I won't watch it again and it will be the first Transformers film I don't buy on Blu Ray. I hate that because I really hoped that Walhberg would help spark the franchise and give it new life. Alas, no. There will, of course, be another one but at this moment I'm not sure I will bother. The magic was gone and I don't know if they can get it back.
Caveat: 10-year old boys will revel in the massive destruction and will like watching the robots fight and turn into cool cars.