NFL Fans - Cam Newton or Andy Dalton

[Townhallsavoy]

Who at this point is the better Rookie of the Year? 

Cam Newton has the better statistics, but Andy Dalton is one of the main reasons why Cincinnati is 6-2 and looking for a playoff spot instead of a new head coach.

[wreckingball]

Who at this point is the better Rookie of the Year? 

Cam Newton has the better statistics, but Andy Dalton is one of the main reasons why Cincinnati is 6-2 and looking for a playoff spot instead of a new head coach.

Cam Newton.

[AUJarhead]

If Carolina has half a defense, they are, at worst, the second best team in the NFC.

[ssgaufan]

I like Cam better, but Dalton will get ROY due to the talent he has around him.  Plus the Bengals are going to make the playoffs while Cam and that horrible Panther Defense sit at home.

[Kaos]

I like Cam better, but Dalton will get ROY due to the talent he has around him.  Plus the Bengals are going to make the playoffs while Cam and that horrible Panther Defense sit at home.

Don't think so.

[JR4AU]

Don't think so.

Agree, everybody is pimping Cam for that now.

[Townhallsavoy]

Don't think so.

Agreed.

Andy Dalton has been a definite surprise, but I think Cam's excitement puts him over the top. 

No need to mention Cam's arm when you consider that his legs have prevented Carolina from being blown out in multiple games.